How Does an Appeal Work, and What if Mine Is Denied?


I want to help you obtain the most favorable outcome possible in your case.

  • Contact me today for a FREE case strategy meeting.
  • Available in-person, by phone, or by video.
Brett Pritchard Law

How Does an Appeal Work, and What if Mine Is Denied?

If you have been charged with a crime, convicted, and sentenced in Texas, it is your legal right to file an appeal against the court’s decision in your case (as long as the court’s decision was not based on your guilty plea). Appeals represent an important legal mechanism for attempting to right wrongs and correct legal errors. If your appeal efforts do not have the effect you hoped for, it can feel like a devastating blow, but it is not necessarily the end of the story.

The Legal Basis for Your Appeal

If you have been convicted of and sentenced for a crime, it is your right to file an appeal with a higher court, which is the appellate court. The intention of an appeal is to review the lower court’s legal decision for legal errors or mistaken judgments. It should be noted here that the U.S. Courts website reports that fewer than nine percent of all appeals, including criminal appeals, led to reversals of lower court rulings in 2015. In making its determination on the case under appeal, the appellate court has three options that include:

  • Uphold the lower court’s ruling, which means your appeal is denied

  • Reverse the lower court’s ruling

  • Modify the lower court’s ruling

If your appeal is denied, there is a next step you can take, which is petitioning the Texas Court of Criminal Appeals.

Requesting a Rehearing

If your appeal is denied, your astute criminal defense lawyer’s first step will likely be to file a motion for a rehearing with the appellate court. This action amounts to a request that the court reverses its original ruling. Still, such a reversal is not likely unless mitigating circumstances or evidence has come to light in the interim. If your motion for a rehearing is denied, you can move forward by submitting a Petition for Discretionary Review in the Texas Court of Criminal Appeals.

Your Petition for Discretionary Review

You have 30 days from the time of your motion for a rehearing to submit your Petition for Discretionary Review with the Texas Court of Criminal Appeals. This petition is a legal document that outlines what makes your case special and why the original appellate court’s decision should be overturned.

Common Issues Behind Appeals

While every appeal has its own unique set of circumstances, there are some common issues that tend to drive appeals, including:

  • The suppression of evidence

  • The suppression of a statement

  • Lack of sufficient evidence

  • Inadequate legal representation

  • Improper jury instructions

  • Misconduct on the part of a juror

  • An unlawful or excessive sentence

Call an Experienced Killeen Criminal Defense Lawyer Today

Attorney Brett Pritchard at The Law Office of Brett H. Pritchard has been serving Killeen, Texas, for more than 20 years, and he is proud to help clients like you obtain just case resolutions – including at the appellate level. We care about your case, so please do not wait to contact us online or call us at 254-501-4040 for more information today.

Related Posts
  • The First Trial Related to the January 6 Attack on the Capitol Convicts a Texas Man Read More
  • What You Need to Know if You Have Been Charged with a Crime in Texas Read More
  • A Closer Look at Plea Bargains in Texas Read More